TOXIC CLOUDS OVER THE BAY
2 months ago NEWZ SUBMITTERS Comments Off on TOXIC CLOUDS OVER THE BAY
We’re all inhaling a toxic cloud of
benzene from gas
CAROL MCALICE CURRIE
July 23, 2008
Letter writers remind Statesman Journal readers almost daily how much cheaper gasoline
would be if only Oregonians were allowed to pump it themselves.
However, no one ever mentions a long-term cost of self-serve gasoline: increased exposure to
benzene, one of Environmental Protection Agency’s 10-most-wanted carcinogens.
According to the state Department of Environmental Quality, Oregon’s gasoline has one of the
highest benzene levels in the country, probably because refineries to the north and south use
Alaskan crude oil, which naturally is higher in benzene.
Oregon also has a high rate of breast cancer (Washington has the nation’s highest rate), yet
residents routinely are told that it has nothing to do with chemicals and more to do with better
reporting methods and Vitamin D deficiencies because of cloudy weather.
According to Environmental Protection Agency, there is no safe level of benzene exposure.
California gas stations all post signs warning pregnant women, the young, the old, the
chronically ill and everyone in between that chemicals known to cause cancer or death are
I know because I designed and wrote the copy for them when I worked for a nonprofit back in
the ’80s BC (before children).
There is a direct link between benzene exposure and cancers of the blood and possibly bone,
but few like to talk about it publicly.
Lisa Arkin, the executive director of Oregon Toxics Alliance, is an exception. She is eager to
cite studies showing that children living within a couple of blocks of gas stations not using
preventive measures to control vapors have a higher chance of developing leukemia.
She also works to get the word out that benzene is considered a genetic mutagen, making me
glad that when I was working and pregnant in Los Angeles, I paid more to let someone else
pump my gasoline.
The online journal Genetics and Molecular Research doesn’t mince words. It cites a 1991
Grandjean and Anderson study, which found a “direct correlation between cancer and
occupational exposure.” The study reported that “lung cancer is the major cause of death
among workers chronically exposed to petroleum derivates (benzene is one).”
That’s one chemical I don’t want to pump weekly, or even monthly for those people driving
A 2006 EPA rule reducing Oregon’s benzene levels in fuel hasn’t altered the benzene content
significantly. So every day, gas- station workers and fuel-truck drivers inhale benzene from the
fuel tanks and pumps, and get an extra shot at a shorter life by breathing in exhaust vapors
1 / 2
And some noisy Oregonians want self-serve to save a few cents per gallon?
Arkin said OTA does not support self-service gasoline for myriad reasons.
“At least gas station workers and fuel-truck drivers are ostensibly protected from their
occupational hazards by OSHA (Occupation & Safety Health Administration), which covers
benzene exposure,” Arkin said. “It’s bad enough to expose these workers. But the public isn’t
trained or protected. We don’t support exposing more people to more risk factors.”
Citing a Lane County Regional Air Protection Agency release, Arkin said 1 ounce of spilled
gasoline causes as much fume or vapor release as driving a car 56 miles. It tracks easily on
clothing and shoes into cars.
OTA has sought to limit benzene exposure since 2000, and it’s making headway.
Last fall, it helped persuade Lane County commissioners to adopt a benzene-reduction policy.
Cities such as Creswell and Corvallis are following suit.
The effort was part of a three-pronged campaign to help communities reduce residents’
exposure to the cancer-causing agent benzene.
To start, OTA recommends that communities require all gas stations to use a dual-hose
system for filling underground tanks. Many newer stations already employ this technology, but
retrofitting and requiring older stations to comply is the organization’s goal.
Dual-hose systems capture displaced vapor from filled fuel tanks, store it and return it to
refineries to be reprocessed into product.
“That keeps vapors out of the air and also reuses them,” Arkin said.
The second OTA goal is to urge gas-station attendants not to top off fuel tanks.
Many newer cars have vapor-lock systems that click off to allow room for vapors to expand into
the neck of the tank. Topping off overrides this function and allows vapors to leak into the air.
Drivers inhale quite a bit of fume along with the station workers.
Finally, OTA is urging “no idling” policies anywhere and everywhere.
Most gas-station attendants require that engines be turned off before tanks are filled, but that’s
not helping in the drive-through lines at banks, restaurants and schools.
An invisible cloud of benzene vapor from exhaust and fuel tanks is being inhaled by workers,
drivers, passengers and passers-by alike. No one is spared. And if you think the vapor cloud
just hangs in the air, think again.
Carol McAlice Currie is a columnist for the Statesman Journal. Contact her at
ccurrie@StatesmanJournal.com, P.O. Box 13009, Salem, OR 97309; or (503) 399-6746; read
her blog at StatesmanJournal.com/valleyvoice.
Copyright © 2008 – StatesmanJournal.com All rights reserved.
2 / 2